Megan McArdle writes on the lack of economics bloggers available, and wonders if professional blogging ultimately will be as difficult to break into as writing for the media.
I'm not sure what this means for the blogging world. It's still largely
an amateur medium, but it's hard to see how many new bloggers can
compete with someone who gets paid to do it, unless they are
independently wealthy or have a job, like journalism or academia, that
routinely throws them a lot of bloggable material. Will it become as
hard to break into blogging as it is to break into print?
The answer to that depends on how you define blogging. If you mean column writing by someone not affiliated with a mainstream publication, then yes, blogging for dollars will be very difficult to get into. The reasons listed by Megan all make sense. Blogging as just writing takes time, and if you aren't payed for that time, it's difficult to create large audiences based your work.
But blogging is more than writing. It's safe to say that blogging is a subset of the wider world of social media, and while political and media bloggers are attempting to replicate or improve upon the publishing world, the vast majority of bloggers, both professional and amateur, are focused on other niches, and it's very easy to break through.
Momblogs, local blogs, sports and hobbies blog, video gaming and music, state and local political blogs, environmental, marketing, and small business blogging are all much bigger (and more lucrative) than blogging about libertarian economics. Heck - blogging about American Idol is more lucrative than blogging about the '08 campaign because there's less competition, a bigger audience, and more ad money.
So never fear about amateur blogging taking off - corporations are putting real time and money into social media, and it's relatively easy to get noticed.
But even in the niche of economics blogging, it's possible to step in and assume a dominant position. Using a host of SEO tricks, social media news submissions, demographic marketing, and clever writing, an economics write could grow traffic and quickly become an A-List blogger. I train people to do this, and all you really need is passion, curiousity, and above-average writing skills. Oh, and a recognition that successful bloggers interact. They leave comments, send e-mails saying thank you, participate in local and national meetings, network profusely, and above all have a focus for their blogging.
Can amateurs do this? Amateurs tend to do it a lot better than professionals, if only because they don't have ulterior motives that shine through (that's the problems with corporate blogging - they want the ROI without the work). The question is why the amateur would do it.
Megan's piece starts out pointing out the lack of a bloggers she could recommend for economics. It's understandable, but it's selection bias. We are all blind, and assume that if we don't know someone in our niche, that they don't exist. The truth is there are lots of qualified people out there who could write on the topic of libertarian economics, but most of the hiring authorities are looking for a cheap way to absorb the traffic of someone already successful.
Basically, they want you to build the audience to get noticed, and they'll pay you a reduced rate to get in front of that audience. If that's what we define as a pool of talent, then of course it will be shallow. The best bargains will be snapped up early, and those that are left will either be profitable on their own or benefit from previous connections. At that point, paying a person to be a professional blogger is the only option. Why should they give their work and reputation away for a reduced rate to a corporation?
The Point (You knew we would get to it some time)
If you are a company or client that wants to hire a blogger, let me make this suggestion. Don't start with the bloggers. Start with what you want to accomplish, and list out what you would define as success
- Is it traffic?
- SEO?
- Media Mentions?
- Blogospheric Street Cred?
- Establishment of an Online Platform for future publishing?
Once you know what you want, begin reaching out to people (or ahem, headhunters), and ask them who they know who could accomplish those goals. Hiring a blogger should not be the point of your writing exercise. Hiring someone who accomplishes your goals is the point.
If they know what to do, they can create the traffic you are looking for. Yes, you have to pay them, but that's not a bad thing for the blogosphere. It's treating blogging as a separate skill, and not a amateurish subset of mainstream publishing.
I know for a fact I could find someone who fits the bill of what Megan's clients need. It may not be what they asked for or what they thought they should hire, but I can find someone to achieve their goals. They may be well-known, or amateur, but they'll be effective. The question is whether they want a blogger, or a columnist who isn't yet paid for what they're worth.